Marc Miller, Canada’s Minister of Immigration, has been in office for nearly 15 months, and after a year of gradual policy adjustments, he finally has some positive results to report regarding the country’s immigration system.
Decline in Foreign Student Visas
Recent statistics reveal a significant drop in the issuance of new and renewed visas for foreign students. In August 2024, there were 97,610 study permits issued, a stark decrease of 45% compared to August 2023, which saw 178,000 permits granted. This decline is crucial, as the previously uncontrolled student visa system had become a breeding ground for immigration fraud and the devaluation of education credentials.
Miller has long acknowledged the issues within the system. However, tangible progress was not reflected in the data until recently. Further data from Miller’s department indicate that this positive trend continued into September, marking a potential turning point for Canada’s immigration policies.
Changes to the Immigration System
Miller has implemented various reforms to communicate to prospective foreign students that simply paying tuition does not guarantee a path to permanent residency. These changes also signal to educational institutions that the unrestricted pursuit of international student tuition revenue is coming to an end.
One of the most significant reforms is the alteration of the post-graduation work permit (PGWP) program. Starting next month, students from universities will still be eligible for PGWPs lasting up to three years. However, eligibility for most college programs will be significantly restricted. Only graduates from programs in five specific fields—agriculture and agri-food, healthcare, science, technology, engineering, and mathematics (STEM), trade, and transport—will qualify to remain in Canada and work.
Miller’s initiatives are commendable, as they mark a step toward rectifying the issues that have plagued the student visa program under the Trudeau government. Nevertheless, there is still much work to be done.
Understanding the Benefits of Foreign Students
To effectively enhance the immigration system, Canada must first understand the benefits of foreign students and how to maximize these advantages. Drawing inspiration from Michael Lewis’s book “Moneyball,” we must transition from intuition-based management to data-driven decision-making in the student visa program.
Why Canada Wants Foreign Students
Two primary reasons drive Canada’s desire to attract foreign students: economic benefits and immigration.
Foreign students often become valuable immigrants because they have already studied and gained work experience in Canada. However, in recent years, Canada has increasingly welcomed immigrants who graduated from lower-quality educational programs, leading to placements in low-productivity and low-wage jobs.
The result has been a misalignment in the immigration system, as evidenced by the University of Waterloo receiving fewer than 1,900 foreign student permits in 2023, while Conestoga College saw its numbers surge to nearly 32,000. This discrepancy illustrates the need for a more strategic approach to immigration, focusing on long-term economic benefits rather than short-term gains.
Examining Employment Outcomes
A recent study by economists at the University of Waterloo, led by Professor Mikal Skuterud, analyzed the labor market outcomes for thousands of graduates. The findings revealed that foreign graduates from Waterloo earn higher salaries than their Canadian counterparts, including those born in Canada.
This data underscores the potential for a targeted approach to student visas, where the limited number of permits is allocated to programs with proven outcomes for high-paying jobs. By doing so, Canada can maximize the contributions of foreign students to its economy.
Reevaluating Current Immigration Practices
While Miller’s recent policy changes indicate progress, they still fall short of completely addressing the underlying issues. The Canadian government continues to focus on the myth of “labour shortages,” allowing certain college programs—often leading to lower-skilled occupations, such as health aides and bus drivers—to remain eligible for student visas and PGWPs.
To optimize the system, Canada must prioritize higher-quality educational programs, akin to the University of Waterloo, rather than those that serve merely as cash-grabs in lower-skilled sectors.
The Financial Incentive for Higher Education
In addition to the potential immigration benefits, foreign students contribute significantly to Canada’s economy through tuition fees. Education functions as an export industry, attracting international students who bring their financial resources to Canada.
Given the finite nature of student visas, priority should be given to programs that charge the highest tuition fees. Notably, many of these programs also produce graduates who are likely to transition into high-wage jobs.
For instance, international students at the University of Waterloo pay between $50,000 and $73,000 in tuition and fees annually, which is roughly four times the international tuition at Conestoga College. This disparity highlights the need for the Ontario government to reevaluate its visa allocation strategy to optimize economic returns.
Implementing a Data-Driven Approach
To effectively “Moneyball” the immigration system, Canada must adopt a dual focus: issuing fewer student visas while targeting programs that yield the most economically productive future immigrants and charge the highest tuition fees. While these two criteria are not identical, they overlap significantly.
The goal is to create an immigration system that not only serves the needs of the economy but also ensures that Canada remains an attractive destination for talented individuals from around the world. This approach could lead to a more sustainable immigration framework that balances economic growth with educational integrity.
Conclusion
Marc Miller’s recent reforms in the immigration system reflect a crucial shift toward addressing long-standing issues within Canada’s student visa program. While progress has been made, there is still a considerable amount of work ahead to ensure that the system is not only effective but also equitable.
By focusing on data-driven policies and understanding the long-term benefits of foreign students, Canada can reshape its immigration landscape. This transformation will enable the country to attract the best and brightest from around the world while maximizing the economic contributions of those who choose to study and eventually settle in Canada.
Related Topics：
