Starting next week, Germany will reintroduce border checks at several crossings, including those with France, as part of a broader plan to curb illegal and irregular immigration. The checks, which will begin on September 16, will also affect borders with Belgium, Luxembourg, the Netherlands, and Denmark. This move, according to Interior Minister Nancy Faeser, marks an expansion of existing checks already in place at borders with Poland, the Czech Republic, Austria, and Switzerland, signaling a significant shift in the country’s immigration control efforts.
A Temporary End to Freedom of Movement
The reinstatement of border checks will effectively suspend the long-standing Schengen Area principle of free movement between Germany and its neighboring countries. The new measures will be enforced for an initial period of six months, with the possibility of an extension beyond that period.
The checks will follow standard procedures, meaning EU citizens will be able to enter Germany with a passport, while non-EU nationals must present either a valid visa, an EU residency card, or a passport stamped under the 90/180-day rule. In addition to targeted checks on certain individuals, authorities will also conduct random inspections of people crossing the borders.
Interior Minister Faeser emphasized that these border checks are part of a larger strategy aimed at combating illegal immigration and bolstering national security. While the minister confirmed that these measures would proceed, she also hinted that further rule changes might allow Germany to reject migrants at its borders, though these plans remain under consideration and could face legal challenges under EU regulations.
Political Context and Motivation
The decision to impose border checks comes at a time of rising political pressure within Germany. The country has witnessed growing support for the far-right party Alternative for Germany (AfD), which recently achieved its first state-wide election victory. Many analysts believe that the reintroduction of border controls is an attempt by the ruling government, a coalition of center-left and centrist parties, to prevent further gains by the AfD.
Germany’s current government, led by the Social Democratic Party (SPD), has been accused by opponents of being too lenient on immigration. The SPD, alongside its coalition partners, has been facing mounting criticism from both the far-right and traditional conservative factions over the country’s migration policies. While the AfD has capitalized on public discontent with immigration, the conservative Christian Democratic Union (CDU), previously led by former Chancellor Angela Merkel, has also come under scrutiny for its handling of migration during the Syrian refugee crisis.
Merkel’s government famously opened Germany’s doors to more than one million refugees fleeing the Syrian civil war, a move that was widely praised internationally but met with mixed reactions domestically. The current SPD-led coalition took a similar approach during the early stages of the Russia-Ukraine conflict, allowing over a million Ukrainian refugees to seek asylum in Germany.
While Germany has long been regarded as a safe haven for refugees and asylum seekers, recent events—including several terrorist attacks—have shifted public opinion on the issue. A recent stabbing spree in Solingen, carried out by a Syrian national, which claimed three lives, has only fueled the debate on whether stricter immigration controls are necessary.
Legal and Diplomatic Concerns
Despite the German government’s decision to tighten border security, the legality of these new measures could be called into question. The Schengen Agreement, which guarantees free movement across much of the European Union, allows countries to impose border checks only under exceptional circumstances, such as threats to internal stability or public safety. Germany’s government appears to be leaning on these exceptions to justify its actions.
Interior Minister Faeser highlighted the rise in terrorist incidents and illegal immigration as key factors driving the policy change. However, the specifics of how Germany might reject migrants at its borders remain undisclosed. There is speculation that the proposal could clash with EU regulations, which generally prohibit member states from turning away asylum seekers at their borders without proper assessment of their claims.
This uncertainty extends to the response of neighboring countries, many of which are already feeling the strain of the reintroduced border checks. Austria, for example, has publicly stated that it will not accept migrants turned away at the German border, potentially leaving individuals in a precarious legal limbo between the two countries.
Wider European Implications
Germany’s decision to reintroduce border controls could have wider implications across Europe, particularly in the Schengen Area, where the freedom of movement is a core principle. The move has the potential to spark further tension between EU member states, especially if the checks are extended beyond six months.
The reintroduction of border controls is also likely to put additional pressure on the European Union to address the issue of irregular immigration in a more coordinated manner. Several EU countries, including Italy, Greece, and Spain, have long struggled to manage the influx of migrants arriving at their borders, with many of these individuals seeking asylum in countries like Germany, France, and Sweden.
The strain on EU immigration policies has been a recurring theme in recent years, with member states often divided on how to handle the growing number of people seeking refuge in Europe. While Germany’s actions may be aimed at addressing domestic concerns, they also underscore the challenges facing the EU as a whole in managing migration in a way that is both fair and sustainable.
Conclusion
Germany’s decision to reinstate border checks represents a significant shift in the country’s immigration policy, reflecting growing concerns over illegal immigration and national security. While the move may be politically motivated, aimed at countering the rise of the far-right, it raises serious legal and diplomatic questions, particularly regarding its compatibility with EU rules on free movement and asylum.
As the border checks go into effect, the German government will need to navigate a complex web of domestic and international concerns, balancing the need to maintain public safety with the principles of openness and solidarity that have long defined the European Union. How this plays out in the coming months will not only impact Germany but could shape the future of immigration policy across Europe.
Related topics:
